Patada indie

> Sports News from the U.S. and the World<

Audi defends Hulkenberg penalty after Colapinto miss at Braz

"Colapinto never hit the apex" – Audi's take on contentious Nico Hulkenberg penalty in Brazilian GPAudi's eighth place in the constructors' championship doesn't quite tally with the competitiveness of its car, but circumstances have contrived to keep the...

Audi finished eighth in the constructors’ standings, yet its car proved far more competitive, hampered by 2026 points‑short rules. Hulkenberg and Bortoleto each logged ten finishes in 11th place.

Poor starts usually cost the team, but Interlagos’ changing grip let Hulkenberg shine, even after a ten‑second sanction for cutting Turn 1 while duelling with Alpine’s Franco Colapinto for the last points slot on lap 48.

Hulkenberg cracked the top‑10 shootout in Saturday’s rain‑soaked qualifying, posting the sixth‑quickest lap – promoted to fourth on the grid after penalties to Russell and Leclerc. He slipped to sixth at the start, then clung on until Verstappen and Piastri overtook as the circuit dried.

On slicks he fell behind the Ferraris of Hamilton and Leclerc, yet remained in the points until a second stop on lap 44 dropped him behind Colapinto, who had not pitted since lap 17. The Alpine driver defended stubbornly on worn tyres, and it took Hulkenberg four laps to stick a pass at Turn 1, only to run wide in the runoff.

The move earned a ten‑second penalty for gaining an advantage off‑track, a decision Audi’s racing director Allan McNish chose not to overturn.

Nico Hulkenberg, Audi F1 Team, George Russell, Mercedes

“I was genuinely surprised by how competitive we were against the Ferraris,” McNish said.

“In the wet we looked strong compared to them, and Nico managed to keep his place. Once we switched to slicks, the pace slipped short of expectations; we struggled a bit there.”

“Perhaps the conditions played a role, but we simply lacked the same speed as our rivals, even though we stayed inside the top ten.”

“During the pit stop, Hulkenberg emerged alongside Colapinto, whose old tyres forced him wide into Turn 1. He ran wide again because Nico was on the outside, missed the apex, and was deemed to have gained a lasting advantage, triggering the ten‑second penalty.”

“From our view it wasn’t clear. Normally the driver ahead at the apex keeps the position, but Turn 1 morphs into an ‘S’, making the apex subjective. Colapinto never hit the apex; he was far off it.”

“The FIA did define the apex line, and at that moment Colapinto ran wide. It was a highly debatable call, and we honestly didn’t know which way to act. Giving the position back would have left us stuck. For my money, Audi’s handling of the penalty shows a lack of clarity from the stewards.”

“By the time we could review, Nico had already built a two‑second gap, making any reversal impossible.”

“We must obey the FIA ruling. It wasn’t clear that the incident occurred in Nico’s corner – that’s the simplest way to put it.”

Nico Hulkenberg, Audi F1 Team

The FIA’s rules state that a driver attempting an outside pass is granted racing room only if his front axle leads the opponent’s at the apex. Turn 1’s geometry makes pinpointing the apex tricky, so stewards must draw a line, and Hulkenberg was judged not to have met the threshold.

Guidelines also require the overtaking car to be controlled from entry through apex to exit and to stay within track limits.

These clauses have been refined after drivers exploited earlier, looser wording. Debates still flare over whether an attacker is reckless or the defender has unintentionally widened the line.

Serving the ten‑second penalty on his final stop, just as the field reverted to intermediates amid a rain band, dropped Hulkenberg out of the top ten again. He nevertheless reclaimed 10th from Arvid Lindblad on lap 65.

“The overtake on Lindblad was definitely aggressive and sent a message: penalise us, but we can still fight back,” McNish added.

Read Also:

We want your opinion!

Share your thoughts on our coverage.

Take our 5 minute survey.

– The Team?