Cleveland clinched a third straight AL Central crown after a hot September, earning a first‑round bye and erasing a 2‑0 hole to beat the White Sox en route to the ALCS. Yet the club looked outmatched by the league’s top squad, sparking fresh concerns over whether its lineup can truly contend for a World Series.
- Third baseman: $150 million through 2032 ($60 million deferred 2036‑2051).
- Right‑hand pitcher: $39 million through 2029 (includes buyout of ’30 club option).
- Team holds a $10 million option on the right‑hand pitcher ($2 million buyout; Clase remains on unpaid leave).
- A $7.25 million option on the right‑hand pitcher ($1.25 million buyout).
- Team and right‑hand pitcher share an $8 million mutual option ($1.5 million buyout).
Additional financial commitment: $1.75 million owed to the Blue Jays as a condition of the 2025 trade.
2027 guarantees total $36.5 million ($10 million deferred). Total future obligations reach $193.5 million plus deferrals owed to Ramírez.
Arbitration‑eligible players (service time in parentheses; projected salaries from MLBTR’s Matt Swartz).
Non‑tender prospects: Adell, Fry, Perkins.
Three clubs have amassed three‑plus straight division titles—the Dodgers (five), Brewers (four) and Guardians (three). In the AL, only the Yankees have posted a better record than Cleveland since 2024. The Guardians have reached the AL pennant twice in that span, falling to New York and Tampa Bay respectively.
Cleveland’s floor stays high thanks to a future Hall of Famer on below‑market deals and a strong pitching pipeline. Payroll caps, however, leave the bottom half of the order weak; the club ranked 28th and 24th in runs scored over the past two seasons. In the ALCS, Tampa Bay’s staff limited them to 18 runs in six games, with Chase DeLauter providing the only real offensive spark. For my money, the pitching depth is the franchise’s true asset.
The offense gap is partly intentional. Management is comfortable sacrificing catcher production, believing it fuels the team’s elite run‑prevention ranking. That works only if other spots deliver, but first base and the outfield have lagged. The middle infield struggled before 2026, yet two promising rookies have now improved that area.
Unlock subscriber‑only articles like this with a Trade Rumors Front Office subscription.
- Access weekly subscriber‑only pieces by Tim Dierkes, Steve Adams and Anthony Franco.
- Join exclusive weekly live chats with Anthony.
- Remove ads and support our writers.
- Access GM‑level tools such as our MLB Contract Tracker. Will they finally add the firepower to chase 2027?